The Monogrammed Muse: How a Stranger’s Scarf Rewrote My Story

Share

View Item

The Find  

I bought the headscarf on a Tuesday, hungover and hating myself.

The thrift store reeked of mothballs and regret. There it was, slung over a rack of ’90s blazers—silk, navy blue, dotted with looping gold initials: E.J.M. Not mine. But the fabric slithered through my fingers like a secret, and for $8, I needed one.

The cashier squinted. “Vintage Hermès knockoff.” I didn’t care.

First Fraud

I wore it to a job interview, my hair unwashed, the scarf knotted like I’d seen in Breakfast at Tiffany’s. The hiring manager, a woman with a razor-sharp bob, eyed the monogram. “E.J.M.… family heirloom?”

“Yes,” I lied.

I got the job.

The Ritual

- Monday Commutes: The scarf trapped subway smells—coffee, diesel, other people’s perfume.

- Bad Dates: A man mocked the initials. “Who’s E.J.M.? Your ex?” I left him with the check.

- Panic Attacks: Unwinding it in bathroom stalls, the silk cool against my wrists.

E.J.M. became my silent alias. I imagined her: Eleanor? Estelle? A spy? A widow? Someone brave enough to leave her initials behind.

The Letter

A coffee spill revealed stitching inside the hem: To Eliza, who makes mornings worth rising for. M.

Eliza Jean Moreau? Eliza June? I Googled, half-drunk, finding nothing but a 2008 obituary for an Edith J. Marlowe, 92, survived by cats.

Not a spy. Not a muse. Just a woman who loved and was loved.

The Unraveling

I wore it to meet my birth mother, the scarf a security blanket. She had the same nose as me, same nervous tuck of hair behind ears. “Pretty,” she said, fingering the silk. “Looks expensive.”

“It’s fake,” I admitted.

She laughed. “So are we.”

The Release

Years later, on a train to Montreal, a girl across the aisle stared. “I love your scarf,” she signed, her hands dancing.

I wrote the story of E.J.M. on a napkin. She read it, eyes bright, and handed me a maple candy.

At my stop, I left the scarf on the seat.

The Echo

Last spring, I spotted it in a flea market—faded, hem fraying. The vendor said a teen girl sold it. “Said it belonged to her pen pal.”

I didn’t buy it back. Some secrets aren’t yours to keep.